Best Broadhead for Elk | Our Buyer’s Guide

When elk hunting, what you need is the deadliest and most efficient kind of an arrow. As a bow hunter, wouldn’t you agree? Elk hunting is an activity that requires a set of skills to perform.

And if you don’t have the right kind of gear for it, your chances of capturing an elk decrease significantly.

This is never good news for both beginners as well as experienced bow hunters. All the more reason to buy the best broadhead for elk, don’t you think?

In the article, we have discussed the seven most suitable options for elk hunting. So you don’t need to scour the market looking for the most appropriate arrow for such a purpose.

The different features and specifications of broadheads are listed down for you below. All you have to do is go through them thoroughly. So let’s get to that right away!

Quick Comparison: Top 7 Best Broadheads for Elk

* Below, you'll find our more detailed reviews, but you can also click the links above to see customer reviews and current prices on

best broadhead for elk

The Best Broadhead for Elk: 7 Top Choices

Bringing down a deer or an elk is something that demands the use of high-quality equipment. And the best broadhead is the way to go. So let’s find out what the top elk broadhead recommendations are.

1. Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead – The Best Mechanical Broadhead for Elk ( Top Our Choice)

Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead

Rage broadheads are considered to be the most reliable models on the market. And the Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead is no different. The best part about these blades is that they have a large cutting diameter. This means they have the ability to cut on impact even with less energy.

You will also be glad to know that it’s not at all difficult to assemble and sharpen the blades. The broadhead may have a compact design, but that doesn’t mean it has poor aerodynamics. The tool is incredibly tough to offer excellent penetration.

Another great feature that you might like is the steel ferrule. Such a reliable quality ensures complete accuracy as well as exceptional aerodynamics.

The part that’s slightly disappointing is the poor quality steel construction. But you should know that broadheads built with steel tend to last longer than the other non-steel options in the industry.

We Like

  • The shock collar ensures excellent blade retention.
  • The unique hybrid tip offers surgical accuracy.

We Don't Like

  • The steel doesn’t provide maximum durability.
  • The blades are dull.

Rage Hypodermic Broadhead Puts Elk Down in 60 yards!

2. Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain Standard Broadhead – The Best Fixed Broadheads for Elk

Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain Standard Broadhead

When it comes to buying fixed broadheads, there’s nothing better than the Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain Standard Broadhead. These blades are affordable and reliable at the same time. They have the ability to deliver cut on impact performance with deep penetration.

The construction is stainless steel, which means additional sustainability. They have a neat, slim design. But don’t let that fool you. The Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain Standard Broadhead is tough enough to withstand all types of harsh conditions.

The most impressive part about it is the geometry of the blade. You don’t have to worry about cutting yourself when sharpening the blade. The only drawback is the small size of the broadhead. This can prove to be a problem as the blade tends to bend after a few uses.

We Like

  • The blades are razor sharp.
  • They work silently.

We Don't Like

  • The broadhead point is susceptible to deformation.
  • They don’t offer flight consistency.

3. G5 Outdoors MontecBroadhead – The Best Broadhead for Elk in Terms of Quality

G5 Outdoors MontecBroadhead

The thing about G5 is that it manufactures superior quality broadheads for elk and deer hunting. These broadheads have the ability to stand the test of time. And the G5 Outdoors MontecBroadhead is no different. It has a stainless steel design, and this is where the broadhead gets its strength from.

The blades have a pyramid design with reinforced steel in the front region. While the rest of the broadhead has a rock solid construction. You will be quite impressed with the blades’ beefy nature. Such a quality is perfect for elk and hog hunters who target big game with heavier bones.

With the G5 Outdoors MontecBroadhead, the chances of the blade breaking down on impact or shearing off after penetration are extremely low. Thanks to the sturdy steel build of the blade.

The part that you might not appreciate is the lack of accuracy and consistency. But this can be easily corrected with deliberate practice.

We Like

  • The sturdy design makes the broadhead suitable for heavy-duty hunting.
  • Re-sharpening the blades is an easy task.

We Don't Like

  • he broadhead’s flight path is inconsistent.
  • It doesn’t offer shot accuracy.

How to Sharpen the Montec Broadhead?

4. Stinger Buzzcut 4 Blade Arrow Broadhead – The Best Fixed Broadhead for Elk with Two Blades

Stinger Buzzcut 4 Blade Arrow Broadhead

The StingerBuzzcut 4 Blade Arrow is the only top quality fixed broadhead built with two blades. The solid construction of the tool ensures cut on impact performance. So you don’t need to worry about the blade not cutting through the flesh easily.

As far as durability is concerned, that’s pretty much covered too. Thanks to the durable stainless steel design of the broadhead. The best part about the Stinger Buzzcut 4 Blade Arrow Broadhead is that it provides exceptional accuracy.

On top of that, the blades have a serrated quality. This means they can cut better, which results in leaving finer blood trails.

So what seems to be the problem with this broadhead for elk? The blade tends to snap when it hits the shoulder blade or any other hard bone. But this only happens on rare occasions.

We Like

  • The wide cutting diameter causes excessive damage.
  • Flight accuracy and consistency are exceptional.

We Don't Like

  • The blades might snap when they strike hard bone.
  • They are dull in appearance.

5. Grim Reaper X-Bow MechBroadhead – The Best Broadhead for Large Blood Trails

Grim Reaper X-Bow MechBroadhead

With a single glance at the Grim Reaper X-Bow MechBroadhead, you will notice just how menacing it looks. The three blades have a barb-shaped design with a thick chiseled tip. So you know that they will penetrate all types of big game with ease.

The Grim Reaper X-Bow MechBroadhead might have a small cutting diameter. But that’s not a drawback. Because it’s as exceptionally efficient as any other broadhead with a larger cutting diameter.

Instead, the thing that’s slightly disappointing is when the blades don’t open. This is a major concern when using mechanical broadheads. But the Grim Reaper X-Bow MechBroadhead makes up for this by supplying a practice head. So you can diligently work at mastering your shot.

We Like

  • The 100% steel construction offers durability.
  • The broadhead has razor sharp, thick blades to leave great blood trails.

We Don't Like

  • The blades might not open on certain occasions.
  • They don’t perform well with hard bone.

Mechanical Broadhead Details

6. Swhacker Set of 3-100 Grain 2 Inch Cut Broadheads – The Most Damaging Broadhead for Elk

Swhacker Set of 3-100 Grain 2 Inch Cut Broadheads

When mechanical broadheads have two expandable blades, expect maximum damage. And that is what the Swhacker Set of 3-100 Grain 2 Inch Cut Broadheads have to offer. They tend to open pretty fast just when the tip hits the prey. So you will not find anything better than these as far as damage and efficiency are concerned.

The primary blades have an exceptional ability to slice through the hide. While the secondary blades offer a remarkable cutting capacity with flesh as well as organs.

You will also be glad to know that this broadhead for elk comes with a carbon steel-equipped chisel tip. This feature ensures deeper penetration.

As is the case with all mechanical blades, this one too fails to open on rare occasions. So it’s important to keep this in mind when you’re trying to decide which broadhead’s better; fixed or mechanical.

We Like

  • The Swhack system with two blades causes extensive damage.
  • The blades are extremely sharp for better penetration.

We Don't Like

  • The ferrule is aluminum and not steel-made, hence less durability.
  • The blades don’t open sometimes.

Why I Use Swhacker Broadheads?

7. Trophy Taker Shuttle T-Lock Broadhead – The Best Lightweight Broadhead for Elk

Trophy Taker Shuttle T-Lock Broadhead

Even though the Trophy Taker Shuttle T-Lock Broadhead has a compact design, it offers high performance. Thanks to the rugged T-Lock arrow. The whole thing boasts a stainless steel construction. On top of that, it comes with a strong load locking system. So you don’t need to worry about efficiency at all.

You will also be glad to know that the Trophy Taker Shuttle T-Lock Broadhead’s blades have a non-vented style curved design. What this does is offer a silent flight path.

Another great feature is the chiseled tip quality of the blades. This is useful in providing deeper penetration even on massive impact.

The problem arises when you get a flat trajectory. The cause of this is unknown, but a little bit of practice might easily correct the issue.

We Like

  • The broadhead delivers accuracy and speed.
  • The thick blades tend to cut bigger holes as well as penetrate deeper.

We Don't Like

  • They are not sharp enough.
  • The flight path of the blades is slightly disappointing.

The Best Broadhead for Elk: Buyer’s Guide

Buying broadheads for elk hunting isn’t an easy task. Do you know why? It’s because there are tons of options to choose from. On top of that, manufacturers are consistently improving the existing technology or adding new features to enhance user experience.

So there are many factors that you, as a bow hunter, need to take into consideration when buying the best broadhead for elk. And that’s what you’re going to learn in this guide. The goal is to make the selection process easier and purchase a broadhead that fits your hunting style and needs.

The Two Different Types of Broadheads

Fixed Broadhead

best broadhead for elk

The best fixed broadheads for elk are the traditional models on the market. These are one piece, single broadheads. They have blades with a cut-on-impact design.

This particular quality makes fixed broadheads suitable for not only elk but also bear and whitetail deer hunting.

These types of broadheads have a diameter of somewhere between 1 and 1.5 inches.

This means that the entry, as well as the exit wound, would be vast enough to guarantee fast bleed. And we all know how important it is to ensure that the animal dies ethically.

The best part about fixed broadheads is that they offer tons of flexibility as soon as they come in contact with bone.

Every blade has its disadvantages as well. The problem with fixed broadheads is that they need to be re-sharpened or their heads need replacement quite often.

Another downside is that fixed blades tend to hinder arrow flight with faster shots.

Mechanical Broadhead

best broadhead for elk

These are expandable or moveable broadheads, unlike their fixed counterparts. They come with the valuable slip cam feature.

What it does is trigger the expansion of the blade. But when in flight, the blade is tucked away to increase the broadhead’s aerodynamics. The newer models in the industry offer a 4-inch cutting diameter.

When mechanical broadheads hit the target, they expand for penetration. Once the entry wound is made, the blades lower drag and increase flight.

This is when they expand further while moving through the flesh.

The disadvantage of mechanical broadheads is their expandable design. With moving parts, the chances of the blade not working increase.

And this is something you don’t have to deal with when it comes to fixed broadheads.

How to Choose the Best Broadhead for Elk?

No matter how hard you try, you will never find two same broadheads on the market. Each blade comes with unique features. But there are a few things that you should take into consideration when buying broadheads. These are standard features; ones that every blade offers to deliver a better elk hunting experience.

The first factor that we’re going to discuss is durability. In fact, it is the most important one. Because you don’t want your broadhead to break down while it’s smashing through the animal’s thick hide, bones, and muscles. The only way to ensure maximum durability is to buy a steel-made broadhead.

Then comes the penetration capacity. How deep can the broadhead travel take down an elk without hitting a second shot? This brings the blade’s sharpness into the picture. So look for a blade with edges that are nothing short of razor sharp.

The last feature to take into account is the broadhead’s quality. High-quality construction, finish and fit are as important as durability.

So you should make it a point to examine the finishing and fit between broadheads. Because if these characteristics are not up to the mark, the tolerance level might get compromised. And you don’t want anything to mess with your performance now, do you?


The best broadhead for elk is one that offers an excellent combination of sharpness and durability. This is useful in making sure that your hunt is not only successful but easier and more convenient as well. So keeping this in mind, we would recommend the Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead.

The Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead is considered to be the best mechanical broadhead for elk. And that’s because of the top quality along with the lethal tip of the blade. The broadhead has a complete steel construction to provide maximum durability. The extremely sharp blades tend to cut deeper, and the hybrid tip causes more damage.

You will be glad to know that the Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead is suitable for both regular bows and crossbows.

On top of that, the shock collar technology does an excellent job at making sure that the blades engage at the correct time. And with easily replaceable blades, you get all the comfort and convenience you need for elk hunting.

You might also like:

Leave a Reply